Skip to main content

BOOK REVIEW: CILKA'S JOURNEY

Cilka's Journey 

by Heather Morris


Firstly I would like to start by clarifying the content used to write this novel, this is a "fictional" story based on some information relayed to the author by Lale Sokolov (The Tatooist of Auschwitz).  Heather Morris is clear on this subject at the end of the novel when she relays where she gained her research, what contributed to it's creation and what she hopes a reader will get from this story.

This is the story of Cilka Klein, a jewish prisoner of Auschwitz who at the age of 16 is wrenched from her family and placed in the women's camp Birkenau, to enable herself and her sister Magda to survive she finds herself not only put in front of Menghele but also ends up in Hut 25, this is where the sick and dying go.

Cilka manages to survive however, carries a large amount of survivors guilt so when she is brought in front of the Russian's who have free'd her she is devastated to find freedom is to evade her.  Cilka is emprisoned in poland where she is a prisoner for conspiring with the Nazi's before finding herself again on a transport train with hundreds of others sent to the arctic circle and arrives at Vorkuta Gulag.

From her arrival Cilka again finds herself with limited options to protect herself as she realises the Russian gulags are a concentration camp by any other name, from her arrival she takes a path and aligns herself with Boris a senior criminal within the camp who can offer her protection but at a price.  As the story goes on we follow Cilka and her fellow hut mates as they traverse the situation laid before them, Cilka will find herself in a situation where the truth is not easy to relay yet she manages to maintain the strength and fortitude of character to continue to help those in need and continually put others health and happiness before her own.

This book is a strong story about an astounding women in Cilka and the things in life she has to contend with, despite the negative publicity this book has received in the press, if this book is taken as a fictional story you will find it unputdownable.  

What astounds me on this book however, is how little information on the Russian gulags has been taught in the UK schooling system, the political, criminal and religious prisoners are exposed to equally as discriminatory and savage surroundings as those enforced by the Nazi's and yet is little discussed.  It also reminds me that I need to read more on this topic as well as the stark realities of the link to Jim Crow and US prisons using prisoners to manufacture products and undertake manual labour roles for companies during their imprisonments and it is both astounding and devastating that this behaviour still is deemed acceptable and undertaken in the current times.

I gave this book 4* and not 5 purely as this was not a biography/true story as that of Lale Solokov, had it been possible for the author to draw on more facts about Cilka's life both before, during and after her imprisonment I think this would be essential reading to expose the atrocities experienced during this time in history.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BOOK REVIEW: The Mist by Ragnar Jonasson

This is the 3rd book in the Hidden Iceland series and returns us back to the life of Detective Hulda prior to the death of her husband and daughter. This case starts in 1987 on an isolated farm house in the east of Iceland.  A severe ice storm at the start of the Christmas celebrations should have prevented anyone from getting to them however, it didn't. The couple should never have let him in. But they did.  Their unexpected guest is telling them a story that doesn't ring true, why is he there and is he the cause of their death. So far I have found this series fast paced and beautifully written.  Starting with The Darkness we are introduced to the characteristic but far from effervescent Detective Hulda Hermannsdóttir, she is a Detective Inspector forced into early retirement at 64 but who fights her cause and manages to convince her boss to review an old case on the murder of a russian women that washed up on the shore,  The amazing and unexpected ending meant I was intrigued

BOOK REVIEW: Blackberry & Wild Rose

by Sonia Velton 4* "...There are no secrets in London " Esther Thorel is a wife of a Huguenot silk weaver, she rescues Sara Kemp from her unfortunate life in a brothel under the pretext of doing gods work however, when Sara begins her maid duties she is not convinced she is any better off but to escape her madam the offer is too good to ignore. In the Thorels Spitalfields home, the ghost of two looms haunts the attic.  As the women's relationship is forged through the physical intimacies between maid and mistress, Sara becomes ever hostile to Esthers inability to see the hypocrisy of her household, too absorbed in her own secrets to believe Sara is a threat. Esther is a painter, keen to transfer her artwork to the craft of silk weaving.  Her husband rebukes her suggestion which forces her to develop a relationship with a journeyman weaver working on the loom in the attic, in the hopes of obtaining his own status as master weaver.  This relatio

BOOK REVIEW: Always Here for You by Miriam Halahmy

Young Adult - Trigger Warning for Child Grooming on the Internet   Holly is 14 and feels alone, her best friend has moved away to Canada and her parents are dealing the normal stresses of both work and home life as well as caring for an elderly member of the family. This has caused Holly to feel both isolated and alone, spending increasingly longer amounts of time fending for herself and in the house alone, where she is terrified of every noise that she hears. Her mum does try to get her to befriend Noah, a boy in her year who is experiencing bullying from another class mate and member of his synagogue. Although Holly does not realise it this friendship may not only save Noah, but also herself. Then Holly meets Jay, someone she believes is friends with her bestie Amy and other people in school as he was posted about on an online forum, quickly this situation gets out of hand and she begins to isolate herself from those she cares about and her personality notably changes. Is Jay what he