Skip to main content

Review: Peter Pan

Image result for Puffin Chalk Edition Peter Pan

 My rating: 4 stars

 This book was read as part of a YouTube readalong with Jen Campbell (@aeroplanegirl)  and is ongoing until the end of August 2016.
Well I have just completed reading this and I have to say it is 

far from the hearts and roses pastel Disney version most 

readers grew up with as a child and would anticipate. 


To be honest at 41 you may be wondering why I chose to 

read this book and it is for two reasons, 

primarily I wanted to extend my reading of classics and 

secondly take part in my first YouTube readalong hosted by 

Jen Campbell during August 2016. 


I am in no way literary far from it and trying to write this 

review is somewhat reminiscent of my misplaced education.

Despite both loving reading assignments and writing fiction 

(of a loose sort) in my brain I am not a deep thinker to the 

intricacies put before me in some written texts until it is 

pointed out to me with a glowing arrow.

In this instance however, I found the the darkness in the 

narration of the story to be a welcome change from bright 

pastel colours and bursting into song.


I found Peter himself to be far from loveable a manipulative 

and cruel individual who lies to both the lost boys and 

Wendy for his own means.  Tinks character however dark is 

masterful and I love the honesty portrayed in her jealousy 

and behaviour towards Wendy.


The darkness of the scenes on Neverland are equally 

unanticipated more from knightmare than dream.  The scary 

loss of memory experienced by all its residents, the dark 

behaviour and lack of moral judgement portrayed not only by 

Pan but by his Lost Boys towards violence.


There is also a somewhat narcissistic way in which   

J.M.Barrie portrays parenthood which makes me want to 

research into his life further and gain where he got the idea 

for the book.  His treatment of women is very much of the 

time the book was written and therefore I don't think 

intentionally meant to be belittling of women, or so you 

would think initially.  The ending however, opened my eyes 

to the era's subjugation and servitude of women and the 

hereditory nature of the women's place in the home at that 

time.

I would recommend this books to lovers of the Pan of your 

youth or a new lover of classics.  It has not tarnished my 

happy Disney experiences of a child, just enlightened me to 

a new Neverland in my adult life.

Enjoy for now

Em
Labels:
Location: Buntingford SG9 9FJ, UK

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: The Mermaid and Mrs Hancock

The Mermaid and Mrs Hancock by Imogen Hermes Gowar My rating: 1 of 5 stars This book is set in 1785 when a merchant Mr Hancock is handed into his possession a shrivelled body of a mermaid in lieu of a ship he was expecting to return. This starts an event of trying to recoup his losses by displaying the oddity to those of interest at a sum. Angelica Neal is a women used to being kept but has fallen on hard times, her previous lover has passed away and she finds herself fighting for survival and recognition to keep herself out of the high paid establishments and prostitution that will be her plight. Instead Angelica seeks a new lover and a higher status than that previously achieved. Despite the high acclaim from my fellow Book Tuber's unfortunately this book did not quite meet my expectation. I found this book to read in a very slow and dry manner which left me unable to connect either with the content of the story or unfortunately the characters....
Post a Comment
Read more

BOOK REVIEW: Always Here for You by Miriam Halahmy

Young Adult - Trigger Warning for Child Grooming on the Internet   Holly is 14 and feels alone, her best friend has moved away to Canada and her parents are dealing the normal stresses of both work and home life as well as caring for an elderly member of the family. This has caused Holly to feel both isolated and alone, spending increasingly longer amounts of time fending for herself and in the house alone, where she is terrified of every noise that she hears. Her mum does try to get her to befriend Noah, a boy in her year who is experiencing bullying from another class mate and member of his synagogue. Although Holly does not realise it this friendship may not only save Noah, but also herself. Then Holly meets Jay, someone she believes is friends with her bestie Amy and other people in school as he was posted about on an online forum, quickly this situation gets out of hand and she begins to isolate herself from those she cares about and her personality notably changes. Is Jay wha...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review: A Portable Shelter

A Portable Shelter by Kirsty Logan My rating: 4 of 5 stars I am not one to always get on with a book based in magical realism however, I had heard such good things about this book I could not resist giving it a chance. This book is based on a gay couple Ruth and Liska who have moved to a remote coastal cottage in Scotland while Ruth carries their first child. Each of them spends time telling the baby stories containing moral and life lessons from what they have learnt. This includes many magical realism tales including selkies, werewolves and child-eating witches. They agree not to tell stories to the baby so each of them are relaying their tales in secret from each other. I really did enjoy the small tales included within the overall story of Ruth and Liska however, was somewhat disappointed when the concluding story was about Death. I felt sad that the child was not born during the final pages of the book and felt extremely curious to find out with a mot...
Post a Comment
Read more